Genentech had asked the court for a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction against Amgen in a Biologics Price Competition and Innovation Act (BPCIA) litigation related to patents covering Herceptin. The United States District Court for the District of Delaware denied Genentech’s motion, and the court has now made public a redacted version of the memorandum opinion in the matter.
Last week, biosimilar developer Amgen launched the first 2 anticancer biosimilars in the US market: Mvasi, a biosimilar bevacizumab referencing Avastin, and Kanjinti, a biosimilar trastuzumab referencing Herceptin.
Genentech, developer of both of the reference products, had previously asked the court for a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction against Amgen in a Biologics Price Competition and Innovation Act (BPCIA) litigation related to patents covering Herceptin. The United States District Court for the District of Delaware denied Genentech’s motion, and the court has now made public a redacted version of the memorandum opinion in the matter.
According to the document, Amgen gave its notice of commercial marketing related to Kanjinti in May of 2018. Four weeks after the biosimilar was approved by the FDA, Genentech moved for the restraining order and preliminary injunction; on the same day, the court ordered a standstill to consider Amgen’s response to Genentech’s motions.
The decision points out that a preliminary injunction is a drastic, extraordinary remedy, and that obtaining such relief requires that a party show a likelihood of success on the merits, prove that it would suffer irreparable harm if an injunction was not granted, show a balance of hardships in its favor, and demonstrate that an injunction would be in the public interest.
According to the opinion, Genentech, however, failed to show that it would suffer irreparable harm if its motion were denied. Given that the reference drug maker had known that Amgen planned to launch its drug since it served its notice in May 2018, and given that Genentech received other information from Amgen in the discovery process that alerted the company to the planned Kanjinti launch date, Genentech’s actions are “contrary to the spirit and purpose of the BPCIA,” which gives parties time to adjudicate these types of matters without asking the court for immediate relief.
“Genentech’s undue delay in requesting a preliminary injunction, particularly in light of relevant provisions of the BPCIA, should be sufficient by itself to deny the motion,” reads the opinion.
However, the opinion also adds that Genentech has licensed patents to biosimilar developers Mylan, Celltrion, and Pfizer for biologics in the past—allowing for biosimilar launch dates that are redacted in the opinion—which suggests that Genentech would not suffer irreparable harm if biosimilar competitors enter the market.
Eye on Pharma: Sandoz Files Antitrust Suit; Yuflyma Interchangeability; Costco’s Ustekinumab Pick
April 22nd 2025Sandoz's antitrust suit against Amgen, the FDA’s interchangeability designation for Celltrion’s adalimumab biosimilar, and the inclusion of an ustekinumab biosimilar in Costco’s prescription program highlight growing momentum to expand biosimilar access and affordability for patients with chronic inflammatory diseases.
How AI Can Help Address Cost-Related Nonadherence to Biologic, Biosimilar Treatment
March 9th 2025Despite saving billions, biosimilars still account for only a small share of the biologics market—what's standing in the way of broader adoption and how can artificial intelligence (AI) help change that?
President Trump Signs Executive Order to Bring Down Drug Prices
April 16th 2025To help bring down sky-high drug prices, President Donald Trump signed an executive order pushing for faster biosimilar development, more transparency, and tougher rules on pharmacy benefit managers—aiming to save billions and make meds more affordable for everyone.
Will the FTC Be More PBM-Friendly Under a Second Trump Administration?
February 23rd 2025On this episode of Not So Different, we explore the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) second interim report on pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) with Joe Wisniewski from Turquoise Health, discussing key issues like preferential reimbursement, drug pricing transparency, biosimilars, shifting regulations, and how a second Trump administration could reshape PBM practices.
Latest Biosimilar Deals Signal Growth Across Immunology, Oncology Markets
April 14th 2025During Q1 2025, pharmaceutical companies accelerated biosimilar expansion through strategic acquisitions and partnerships in hopes of boosting patient access to lower-cost treatments in immunology and oncology.
Experts Pressure Congress to Remove Roadblocks for Biosimilars
April 12th 2025Lawmakers and expert witnesses emphasized the potential of biosimilars to lower health care costs by overcoming barriers like pharmacy benefit manager practices, limited awareness, and regulatory delays to improve access and competition in chronic disease management during a recent congressional hearing.